Bethany College had a total enrollment of 615 students in 2024. The full-time enrollment at Bethany College is 570 students and the part-time enrollment is 45. This means that 92.7% of students enrolled at Bethany College are enrolled full-time.

The enrolled student population at Bethany College, both undergraduate and graduate, is 49.8% White, 24.2% Hispanic or Latino, 18.4% Black or African American, 1.95% American Indian or Alaska Native, 1.3% Two or More Races, 0.813% Asian, and 0.325% Native Hawaiian or Other Pacific Islanders.

Students enrolled at Bethany College in full-time Undergraduate programs are most commonly White Male (24%), followed by White Female (22.6%) and Black or African American Male (15.8%). Students enrolled in full-time Graduate programs are most commonly Black or African American Male (50%), followed by White Male (25%) and Hispanic or Latino Male (25%).